What happened and why you should act now

TechRepublic reports holiday fraud in 2025 is accelerating as attackers combine AI, automation and large stolen-data pools to run bigger, faster scams. The high-level shift matters because it changes how quickly fraud can scale and how traditional manual review teams get overwhelmed. Below you'll find practical, non-technical steps you can take to use automation and smart tooling to reduce chargebacks, stop account takeovers and protect revenue this season.

How fraud is changing — the key details

Fraudsters now use generative AI to craft believable phishing messages, automated scripts to test stolen card numbers at scale, and bots to create and abuse accounts. That raises two big problems for businesses: higher false positives from blunt rules, and a spike in volume that outpaces human review. The typical tactics include AI-written phishing for credential harvesting, bot-led checkout stuffing, and synthetic accounts used to game discounts or launder goods.

For businesses that accept online payments or manage accounts, the technical takeaway is simple: manual processes and rigid rule sets won't keep up. You need layered defenses (device signals, velocity checks, behavioral profiling) tied to automated workflows that act in real time rather than waiting for batch review.

Who’s affected and the business impact

Retailers, e-commerce sellers, subscription services and any business using digital wallets or stored credentials are at highest risk. Expect three measurable impacts if you don’t act:

• Revenue leakage: Chargebacks and lost goods lower margins — many SMB retailers report 1-3% revenue erosion in heavy-fraud months; during a major attack that can double.
• Operational overload: Manual review teams can spend 20-40 hours/week just triaging suspicious orders during the holidays, delaying fulfillment and harming customer experience.
• Reputation and trust: Credential stuffing and account takeovers hit recurring revenue and customer lifetime value when users abandon breached accounts.

Stopping these requires both smarter detection and automation to remediate issues quickly without blocking legitimate customers.

Immediate actions you can take in the next 0–14 days

Start with low-friction changes that cut risk fast. These steps are practical for non-technical owners and can be implemented within days.

• Enable payment provider protections: Turn on features like Stripe Radar or your PSP’s fraud rules, set medium sensitivity, and review blocked transactions daily. This typically takes under 1 hour and reduces obvious bot traffic by 20-40%.
• Enforce multi-factor on sensitive flows: Add MFA for account changes, password resets, and high-value checkouts. Using tools like Auth0 or built-in identity features in Shopify/ShopRunner can be done in a day and cuts account takeover rates significantly.
• Deploy device and behavioral signals: Turn on device fingerprinting and velocity checks in your fraud stack (Forter, Kount, Sift). These detect automated attempts and reduce false positives when tuned.
• Automate low-risk remediation: Use Zapier or Make.com to flag suspicious orders into a Slack channel or a helpdesk ticket in Zendesk for quick manual review — saves teams 8-12 hours/week versus manual exports.

30–90 day automation roadmap

After the quick wins, build automation that scales with traffic and reduces manual workload.

• Integrate a fraud engine with order flow: Use an API-capable service (Forter, Riskified, Sift) to score orders and automatically route high-risk transactions to a hold state or manual review queue. Expect implementation to take 2–6 weeks depending on your platform.
• Automate evidence collection: Create a workflow (Make.com or Zapier) that pulls order metadata, device signals and recent login history into a single ticket for reviewers. That cuts review time from ~10 minutes per order to 2–3 minutes.
• Automated customer challenges: For medium-risk orders, trigger an automated CAPTCHA, email verification, or SMS OTP using Twilio or your identity provider. This filters bots while preserving conversions.
• Chargeback automation: Set up automated case assembly for chargeback disputes using webhook triggers to collect receipts, delivery confirmation, and customer communications into a formatted response. Tools like Chargehound or Midigator can automate parts of the disputes process and improve win rates by 10–20%.

Tools and practical integrations

Here are tools you can realistically combine today:

• Stripe Radar: Payment-level rules and machine learning; free with Stripe account base, advanced features on paid tiers.
• Sift or Forter: Full fraud platforms with device signals and policy management. Good for mid-market and up, pricing varies.
• Make.com / Zapier: Glue automation to route alerts to Slack, CRM, or helpdesk; plans from $9/mo to $29+/mo depending on usage.
• Twilio Authy: SMS/voice OTP and programmable messaging for verification; pay-as-you-go pricing.
• Chargehound / Midigator: Dispute automation to speed chargeback responses and improve recovery rates.

Combining a fraud engine with Zapier/Make workflows and an automated dispute tool gives you both prevention and remediation with a modest tech investment.

How to measure success and expected ROI

Track KPIs weekly: chargeback rate, orders flagged, manual review hours, and false-positive rate. Realistic targets for the first 90 days: reduce chargebacks by 20-40%, cut manual review hours by 30-60% and improve dispute win rates by 10-20% when using automated evidence collection.

Example ROI: a small retailer processing $200k/month with 1% fraud loss ($2k) can save $400–$800/month from fraud reduction and reclaim 10–20 hours/week of staff time (worth $500–$1,000/month) — automation can pay for itself inside one holiday season.

Looking ahead — staying adaptive after the holidays

Fraud will keep evolving. Make your defenses modular so you can swap in new signal providers or raise automation thresholds without heavy engineering. Schedule a fraud playbook review every 60 days: tune rules, add new device signals, and iterate on customer challenge flows. That keeps you resilient across peaks.

TechRepublic

Want a quick audit of your setup? Book a free consultation to map fraud risks to automation steps and tools for your business.